Never got into Infamous, but I thought it was pretty popular and most people liked it?
I mean it was a fun B game where you run around doing repetitive stuff while using superpowers and tearing up the town. The combat depth and gameplay was always pretty shallow and closer to stuff like AC1/2. It started off pretty janky with some bad platforming and real ugly and got more polished as the games went along with Second Son/First Light being really polished repetitive shallow experiences. Even then they were still good "B" or 8/10 kind of games.
I enjoyed them all, but wouldn't say any of them were great. Second Son/First Light sure looked nice though and were great for taking photomode pictures. My biggest complaint with those games is their Seattle map sucks and is nothing like real Seattle. At least Last of Us II finally gave a good Seattle map in games.
Infamous #2's expansion was probably the tightest and best of them where you're a vampire fighting vampires. It was still super repetitive, but it was short and their New Orleans map was really good and no one else did New Orleans in a sandbox until RDR2 so it was a fresh location.
tl;dr - if Tsushima is an 8/10 B game that's good fun & looks nice but repetitive and shallow, then yeah that's basically par for course for Sucker Punch.